Tendie Bot

Tendie.bot

Login
SPY Articles
reddit/

Why SPY Became the Benchmark Everyone's Talking About

Retail investors on Reddit are having a reckoning with the S&P 500, fueled by the Fed chair transition, a humbling performance audit, and a value fund that's beating the market without a single tech stock.

  1. A Reddit user's detailed performance audit found they barely beat

    SPY
    $SPY before taxes — and likely underperformed after.

  2. Kevin Warsh's first day as Fed Chair brings a historical tailwind: the S&P 500 has posted positive returns in 86% of Fed transition years.

  3. A value fund with zero tech exposure is beating the S&P 500 by 4.1% annualized — sparking a debate on r/ValueInvesting about whether the index is overvalued.

On a day when Kevin Warsh officially takes the reins at the Federal Reserve, retail investors across Reddit are doing something unusual: they're measuring themselves against the S&P 500 — and coming away humbled.

SPY
$SPY jumped to the No. 9 spot on Tendie.bot's ticker rankings on June 17, driven by a mix of self-reflection, macro news, and a value fund that's quietly crushing the index without touching a single AI stock.

SPY

The Retail Investor Reckoning

The most resonant post of the day came from r/investing, where a user laid out a detailed accounting of their stock-picking performance against the S&P 500. After time-weighting returns, adjusting for deposits, and factoring in cash drag — the idle 15-20% of capital waiting for entry points — they found their active sleeve returned roughly 11.2% annualized.

SPY
$SPY returned 10.8% over the same period. A 40-basis-point edge — erased entirely by short-term capital gains taxes.

The post struck a nerve. It racked up 220 upvotes and 142 comments, many from users sharing similar experiences. The thread became a de facto group audit, with retail investors confronting the gap between how they feel about their returns and what the numbers actually show.

On r/wallstreetbets, the mood was rawer. One heavily upvoted post (3,500+ upvotes) captured the opposite end of the spectrum — a trader who has lost every position taken since June began, including

SPY
$SPY puts and calls, and now feels like 'exit liquidity' for the broader market. The sentiment underscores a growing anxiety that even the index itself has become a difficult vehicle to time.

A New Fed Chair and a Historical Tailwind

Wednesday also marked Kevin Warsh's first day as Federal Reserve Chair, with markets expecting rates to remain at 3.50%-3.75%. A Benzinga analysis of the past seven Fed Chair transitions since 1970 found that the S&P 500 has historically delivered an average 1-month return of 2.3%, with 86% of episodes posting gains. Over 12 months, the average return rises to 7.9% — again with 86% positive outcomes.

The data offers a constructive backdrop for the index, though it comes during a period when tech-heavy ETFs have surged 40-45% since late March — far outpacing the S&P 500's 17% gain, according to a Motley Fool report. That divergence has pushed tech valuations to uncomfortable levels, with P/E ratios ranging from 34 to 44 compared to the S&P 500's 20.1.

SPY
$SPY

The Anti-Tech Value Fund That's Beating the Index

A Barron's article shared widely on r/ValueInvesting added a fascinating counterpoint to the day's index-focused discussion. The Moerus Worldwide fund, managed by Amit Wadhwaney, has posted a 17.9% five-year annualized return — beating the S&P 500's 13.8% — without owning a single tech or AI stock. Wadhwaney describes AI valuations as nonsensical, instead holding positions in UniCredit, Natura Cosmeticos, and energy firms.

On r/ValueInvesting, the post sparked debate about whether the S&P 500's tech-heavy composition has made it a riskier benchmark than many investors realize. The fund's outperformance — nearly double the average foreign small/mid-cap fund's 9.6% return — offers a real-world example of beating the index by going where it doesn't.

What the Data Shows

Sentiment: 47% bullish, 32% bearish, 21% neutral.

Reddit sentiment around

SPY
$SPY was broadly neutral-to-bullish on June 17, with an average sentiment score of 0.47. The index saw 449 comments and 169 upvotes across 7 posts — modest volume compared to meme stocks, but highly concentrated in substantive discussion threads. The jump to No. 9 in the rankings (up 8 positions from the prior day) reflects a shift in conversation quality as much as quantity.

Subscribe to Tendie.bot for more market recaps.