Reddit joins the S&P 500 on August 18, replacing AvalonBay Communities. The stock surged 16% on the news.
Retail investors are debating whether Reddit’s AI data deals with Google and OpenAI offset the risk that AI Overviews reduce Google search referrals to the platform.
Q2 earnings showed robust growth: revenue of $805 million (+61%) and U.S. ad revenue +64%, supporting the bull case that monetization can outpace traffic shifts.
Reddit (![]()
The AI Data Dilemma
![]()
Bulls Point to Monetization Strength
The counterargument, echoed in r/ValueInvesting, is that Reddit’s Q2 earnings demonstrate monetization can outpace traffic headwinds. Revenue surged 61% to $805 million, ad revenue rose 64%, and U.S. revenue per user climbed 51% while daily active users grew just 6%. One user described Reddit’s moat as “addictive and valuable,” arguing the platform has no real competitor and could 10x from here. A r/investing post citing a Moneyweek column noted that analysts believe combined Google and OpenAI deals could dramatically boost profitability, calling the renegotiation a potential “make or break” moment.
Amid the debate, a comparison piece from The Motley Fool on August 15 pitted ![]()
What Retail Investors Are Watching
Reddit’s S&P 500 entry is a clear catalyst, but the discussion on r/investing remains divided. The stock has slid 40% this year before the index news, and the AI traffic threat lingers. Bulls argue the company’s monetization gains and unique data licensing position make the risk worth taking. Bears warn that a Google renegotiation could expose just how dependent Reddit is on a single search partner.
Subscribe to Tendie.bot for more market recaps.
